Skip to main content
SearchLoginLogin or Signup

Library Support for OA Books Workshop: the German perspective.

COPIM, OPERAS-P and open-access.network workshop in Germany

Published onAug 06, 2020
Library Support for OA Books Workshop: the German perspective.
·

This summer, as part of the WP2, we started a series of European-based workshops, aiming at gaining a better understanding of the national-specific issues surrounding collective funding for OA books from a library perspective. The first online workshop took place on July 30th 2020.

The event was organised jointly by three European projects. COPIM, open-access.network and OPERAS-P came together to host a workshop that brought together library and university presses representatives in Germany. Despite the Urlaub period being in full swing, we managed to gather a handsome number of participants from different institutions and regions. From Karlsruhe to Berlin: we all sat down in our respective living rooms to discuss possible futures of OA books in the German context. The workshop was divided in two parts: the first one focused on the main challenges that libraries encounter when supporting OA books-related initiatives, while the second one evolved around a discussion among a proposed model for collaborative funding for OA books. A number of recurring themes emerged from our discussion.

One size doesn’t fit all

National uniqueness was raised multiple times by our German colleagues and was expressed in several contexts. It was noted that Germany’s federal structure results in the multiplicity of regional policies and workflows used in the academic library systems. Institution-specific OA funds and policies further strengthen the idea of individual institutions as individual players with their individual interests in mind.

Decentralisation also determines a multiplicity of approaches towards OA and it became apparent that a one size fits all model is simply not sustainable in the German context: what would work in Saxonia might be completely incompatible with the existing infrastructures in North Rhine-Westphalia. 

The existing infrastructures and networks make for a lively, yet complicated landscape of OA in Germany. A plethora of OA-related projects exists, with the open-access.network, the National Contact Point Open Access or the recent ENABLE! initiative proving that the soil is fertile for OA-monographs related discussions. In terms of the BPC-alternative collective funding models for OA books, Knowledge Unlatched is the most recognisable actor on the German market, with the majority of the workshop participants being familiar with its scheme. There is also a strong tradition of university presses in Germany,  promoting open access and publishing OA books.

It was therefore suggested that any new OA book initiative, based on collaborative funding, if it is to be successful in Germany, needs to recognise these unique national circumstances.


On scarcity and abundance: the road blockers

When asked about the main challenges in facilitating OA books-related initiatives the participants identified several features conspicuous by their scarcity in the German setting: funding, resources, OA book coverage in main discovery systems and OA-awareness among authors. It was also pointed out that workflows surrounding OA books are complex and difficult to handle, especially when it comes to legal frameworks and licensing.

On the other hand, it turns out that the abundance of choices might be just as challenging as the lack thereof. Participants voiced their frustration over the multiplicity of existing OA book initiatives, often operating on different business models and offering different services. This plethora of options makes it difficult to make a sound decision as to which project to support and which to reject.

Yes or no?

How do libraries in Germany decide on supporting OA book initiatives? Among the important factors influencing these decisions the issue of transparency perhaps shone the brightest. Participants discussed both transparency in the governance structure, where a non-commercial and collaborative character of proposed initiatives ranked high and transparency in cost calculations, where a fair deal was asked for. Its fairness, rather than on low prices, was to be based on clear cost calculations, so that all stakeholders would be aware of how the money is spent and what it is exactly that they are paying for. They were also in favour of open-source software used in the development of any proposed initiatives and called for a tangible output and easily measurable benefits, which would justify the institution’s engagement in any given project.

The question of OA content quality was hotly debated in the breakout room discussions. The need for “seals of approval” coming from existing actors such as Scopus or legacy publishers was frequently noted. Such an approach makes the shift towards innovative models based on open infrastructure and collaboration somewhat challenging in Germany. Participants stressed the fact that the proposed content, rather than any given business model, is what constitutes the final yes or no for libraries. “We are buying content, not a business model”- we heard one participant saying, expressing what seemed like a common need among participants: the need for control over a title-based selection of OA books.

Thank you to our co-hosts and all the participants: we have learned a great deal from you! This event was the first one of the series of European-based workshops in which we talk about issues surrounding collective funding models for OA books. Our next stop this summer is Central Europe, so stay tuned for more insights from the Polish perspective!


*Image of the Reichstag dome by Oh-berlin.com, under CC-BY 2.0

Comments
3
?
Medline Academics:

Are you passionate about pursuing Fellowship in Reproductive Medicine? Do you also wish to be at the forefront of cutting-edge treatments like IVF, helping infertile couples overcome their challenges? Here comes Padma Shri Dr. Kamini Rao's Medline Academics to achieve your objectives and earn your fellowship in reproductive medicine. The recent surveys and studies suggest that the demand for the course is higher compared to Maternal Fetal medicine or  any branch of embryology and life sciences. It is spreading like a trend amongst all the doctors from the field of obstetrics and gynaecology. What’s more surprising is the age factors amongst these doctors. Not just the young doctors who have recently completed their post-graduation, but also professionals who are experienced for more than 3 decades are part of this course.

Fellowship in Reproductive Medicine in India is undergoing a revolutionary upsurge, because to developments in assisted reproductive technologies that are reforming the way infertility is treated. Ambitious medical doctor can choose from a wide range of programs at Medline Academics, including highly sought-after fellowship programs that fit their busy schedules and help them advance their knowledge and abilities.

Reproductive medicine courses in India have experienced a notable improvement in the recent times. The technologies, which range from IUI to IVF, have enabled healthcare experts to treat infertility issues with a level of accuracy that was never possible before. The field of infertility treatment has completely changed as a result of advancements in assisted reproductive technologies (ART), giving hope to innumerable couples who are having difficulty becoming pregnant.

Enter Medline Academics

Medline Academics stands out as a leader in reproductive medicine education amidst this changing environment. The distinguished Padma Shri Dr. Kamini Rao, a pioneer in the field, founded the institute, which is well-known for its unflinching dedication to promoting innovation in reproductive healthcare and medical education.

Comprehensive Fellowship Programs

Aspiring physicians can choose from extensive fellowship programs at Medline Academics that are customized to meet their unique requirements and goals. Whether you are a recent graduate seeking a rewarding career path or an experienced practitioner seeking to specialize in reproductive medicine, our fellowship programs provide the ideal balance of didactic knowledge and practical experience.

Why should you do a Fellowship in Reproductive Medicine?

Starting a reproductive medicine fellowship at Medline Academics is a life-changing event that will influence healthcare in the future, not just an academic endeavour. Fellows work with peers who are as passionate about reproductive health equally, collaborate with expert specialists, and participate in cutting-edge research in a dynamic learning environment.

The foundation of contemporary reproductive medicine, in vitro fertilization (IVF), is strongly emphasized in the fellowship programs offered by Medline Academics. Fellows get comprehensive training that gives them the knowledge and confidence to navigate the challenges of in vitro fertilization (IVF), from knowing the nuances of ovarian stimulation procedures to mastering embryo transfer techniques.

The Simulation Lab

At Medline Academics, we recognize that delivering an exceptional educational experience involves more than simply having outstanding teaching professionals. It also calls for cutting-edge facilities and resources. Our institute has state-of-the-art labs, clinical facilities, and simulation centres that give fellows the resources they need to succeed in their training.

Fellows get the chance to work together with colleagues from other backgrounds, exchanging ideas and viewpoints that enhance their education. Collaboration is ingrained in all aspects of our fellowship programs, whether it is through case discussions, seminars, or research projects.

Opening Doors to Opportunity

Medline Academics gives fellows plenty of networking and professional development opportunities in addition to top-notch education. Fellows have access to a variety of activities that equip them for professional success, from attending conferences and workshops to taking part in clinical rotations and internships with the institution itself.

Choosing to pursue a fellowship in reproductive medicine at Medline Academics in India is a pledge to inducing the direction of reproductive healthcare, not just an academic decision. We are giving future medical professionals the apparatuses they need to succeed in this fast-paced industry and enable them to meaningfully improve the lives of countless people and families around the globe. We therefore warmly invite you to join us at Medline Academics and contribute in this life-changing event if you're prepared to set out on a path of personal development, exploration, and invention.

We also offers: basic infertility course, embryology courses in Bangalore, fellowship in embryology, andrology online course.

Find out more at www.medlineacademics.com

Ruturaj Kulkarni:


The workshop held in Germany highlighted the complexity and diversity of OA book initiatives, emphasizing the need for tailored approaches and transparent governance structures. Participants stressed the importance of content quality and clear cost calculations in decision-making processes for supporting OA book projects. if you are looking for clinical research courses click here

?
Simon Worthington:

Thanks for the insightful blogpost on the German OA Monograph scene - do you maybe have a link to a list of participants would be interesting to see who was inputting to the discussion? And do you have more workshop dates after Poland?